Why I don’t like Lovecraft

I’ve been putting the books I’ve read on Goodreads – partially to show off, but mainly to get recommendations on other books I may want to read. One of the authors who keeps coming up in the recommendations is H.P. Lovecraft.

I realise this is controversial, but I don’t like Lovecraft. I find (a) I can’t really sympathise with his lead characters who all seem self absorbed and over intellectual and (b) his way of creating atmosphere is to describe lots of things as unknowable. His basic message is that the universe is at best uncaring and at worst malign – and there is nothing much we can do about it.

Contrast Lovecraft with my favourite writer of horror stories – Fritz Leiber. Leiber’s main characters are flawed – often mirroring his own problems with alcoholism. Like Lovecraft’s characters they often endure the horrors of the universe rather than defeat them, but they normally manage to pull some lesser and more human triumphs out of their encounters with evil. The basic outlook is therefore optimistic rather than pessimistic.

Leiber is often credited (with some truth) with pioneering urban horrors. His malign beings are creations of the modern world – the smog ghost, the black gondolier of the oil fields, the succubus of advertising. They are not dark demons from hell or destroying aliens from other dimensions. they are the personifications of our own failings. Often they will relate to the devils in side out own heads from our Jungian Ids or all too human frailties. They are here and now and inside all of us, which is why his characters suffer but ultimately overcome in some way, and why we can sympathise with them.

In Lovecraft’s world, shit happens. In Leiber’s we have to get our shit together.

Leiber was very influenced by Lovecraft in his early days as a writer and did write some Mythos stories, but as he became his own man he drew on his own experiences to be a much more human and humane writer than Lovecraft. Perhaps that is why it is easier to pastiche Lovecraft than Leiber. It’s easier to write scenery than psychodrama.

1 thought on “Why I don’t like Lovecraft

  1. franzwesten

    Lovecraft remains a conundrum to me, I devoured his work when I first discovered it, but since then have found some of his stories difficult to revisit. I can vividly remember first reading his work, it was something entirely new to me, and the stories carry such an intense mood, it is still quite unique. Why I find some them difficult now, I am not sure, Clark Ashton Smith, I can happily revisit for example, but Lovecraft remains in my mind, like a fever dream.

    Leiber, I have no problem revisiting, and after 25 years, I can’t see it changing. I think you are correct that it is Leiber’s characters that often stay in the mind.

    Despite the frights, Fritz is never a cruel or malicious writer, but he can be painfully honest, which can be more difficult to deal with. There is often a journey of self discovery too, which always helps one identify with a character.

    I have to say I like Lovecraft, his writings, them fever dreams I mentioned, which is the way I see them, is something I am grateful for experiencing, it widened my world.

    Fritz? He still does that today, every time I open one of his books.



Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s